REAL WORLD LESSON · PROGRAMS TO PROCESS
“Our Biggest Fall Festival Ever”
How a church turned its biggest event from a destination into a first step
Almost every church has one: the big annual event. A fall festival, a trunk-or-treat, Vacation Bible School, an Easter egg hunt. Hundreds of people come. Volunteers work for weeks. Everyone calls it a huge success.
And then, a month later, almost none of those families have ever been seen again. This lesson listens in as one church celebrates its event, discovers the problem, and slowly changes how it thinks: from running a program to building a process.
AROUND THE TABLE
Pastor Steve, the lead pastor
Denise, the children’s director, who has run the fall festival for nine years
Tony, a deacon who oversees the budget
Maria, a mom of two who serves on the welcome team
Part 1: The program mistake
It’s the first week of November. The team meets to debrief the fall festival. The numbers in brackets mark the problems explained after the scene.
THE NOVEMBER DEBRIEF
Tony: Well, I have to say it. Best one yet. Denise, the count at the gate was 640 people! [1]
Denise: Fifty-two trunks, two bounce houses, the face painting line went around the building. We went through almost 900 pounds of candy.
Pastor Steve: That’s incredible. That’s 640 people from our community on our property. What a great outreach.
Denise: And I already have ideas for next year. A hayride, a petting zoo, maybe a food truck. We can make it even bigger. [5]
Tony: We’ll find the money. People love it.
Maria: Can I ask a question? Do we know if any of those families have come to church since?
A pause.
Denise: Well, we put a flyer for Sunday services in every candy bag. [3]
Pastor Steve: And we’re planting seeds. That’s the important thing. God will grow them in His time. [6]
Maria: I just wondered, because I didn’t see any new families the last few Sundays.
Tony: It takes time. But 640 people! Let’s give Denise a round of applause.
Everyone claps. The meeting moves on to the Christmas program.
WHAT NOBODY SAID OUT LOUD
The flyers: The custodian picked up more than a hundred of them from the parking lot the next morning.
The volunteers: The same 40 people worked every station, every year. Most of them spent the night handing out candy and refilling the bounce house line. Few of them had a real conversation with a guest. [4]
The families: Two new families visited on a Sunday in November. Neither came back. Nobody knew they had been at the festival, because nobody had met them there. [2]
Where it went wrong
[1] Success was measured by the size of the crowd.
“640 people” felt like the goal. But the church never decided what it wanted to happen for those people after they left.
Course connection: Measurements · Creating a Vision
[2] The event was a destination, not a step.
The festival had a beginning and an end, and nothing after it. There was no clear next step for a family who had a good time and might be open to more.
Course connection: Place the Program · The Big Checkpoints
[3] Follow-up was a flyer in a candy bag.
A piece of paper can’t start a relationship. People come back because of a person, not a flyer.
Course connection: Making It Personal
[4] Volunteers were workers, not hosts.
Forty church members were on site with 640 guests, and almost all of them were busy running activities. The people best placed to make a connection never had the chance.
Course connection: Church Wide and Individual
[5] The answer to “no results” was “make it bigger.”
More bounce houses and a petting zoo would add cost and work, but not change the outcome. A bigger program is still a program.
Course connection: What Goes and What Stays · Adjusting Ministries
[6] “Planting seeds” replaced tracking.
Trusting God with the results is right. But “planting seeds” also became a reason not to ask whether anyone had taken a next step.
Course connection: Tracking and Measurements
Part 2: The transition to process
Maria’s question stuck with Pastor Steve. In January, he asks the team to meet again, this time to plan next year’s festival differently.
THE JANUARY PLANNING MEETING
Pastor Steve: I keep thinking about Maria’s question. We put a lot into the festival, and I don’t think we know what it’s for. Before we plan anything, can we answer that? What do we want to happen for a family who comes to the festival? [1]
Tony: I guess… we want them to come back?
Denise: To come to church. To get to know us.
Pastor Steve: So if our path is Explore, Connect, Grow and Serve, the festival lives in Explore. Its job isn’t to be the biggest night of the year. Its job is to start a relationship and offer one next step. [2]
Maria: Can I share something? I don’t think I’ve ever told this group how my family came to Grace.
Pastor Steve: Please.
Maria: Eight years ago we came to the fall festival. Honestly, just for the free candy. I was standing at the hot chocolate table, and an older woman named Joan started talking to me. She asked my name. She asked my son’s name, and found out he was obsessed with Legos. Two weeks later, she called and invited us to a Lego night the kids’ ministry was having. Then she sat with us the first Sunday we came.
Maria: I didn’t come back because of the festival. I came back because of Joan.
The room is quiet for a moment.
Pastor Steve: So the process already worked once. By accident. What if we did on purpose what Joan did by accident? [3]
Denise: But I need every volunteer just to run the stations.
Tony: What if we didn’t add the hayride and the petting zoo? Use that money and those people differently? [5]
Denise: Fewer stations… more Joans.
What they decided
Over the next few months, the team made a handful of changes. None of them were complicated.
They designed the next step before the festival. [2]
A “Family Lego & Pizza Night” three weeks after the festival, built for families with young kids. Every invitation at the festival pointed to that one night.
They turned volunteers into hosts. [4]
They kept fewer activity stations and added “front porch” tables with hot chocolate and chairs. Twenty members were trained for 15 minutes on one simple goal: learn names, ask a question, and invite. The rest ran a smaller, simpler set of activities.
They asked members to invite their own neighbors. [4]
Instead of only advertising to the whole community, Pastor Steve asked each family in the church to personally invite one neighbor family and to be there to welcome them.
They followed up personally within 48 hours. [3]
When a family shared their contact information with a host, that same host texted them within two days, often with a photo from the festival photo booth and a reminder about Lego Night.
They built a second checkpoint after that. [2]
At Lego Night, the same hosts were there. Families were invited to a “Family Sunday” in December and offered someone to sit with, just like Joan.
They changed what they measured. [6]
Instead of “How many came?” the team agreed to track three numbers: how many families shared contact information, how many took a second step, and how many took a third.
They changed the language. [5]
Internally, they stopped calling it “our big outreach event” and started calling it “the first step.” Volunteers became “hosts.” It reminded everyone what the night was for.
THE NEXT NOVEMBER DEBRIEF
Tony: Okay. I’ll be honest. When I saw the gate count, I was nervous. 450 people. That’s almost 200 fewer than last year.
Denise: But look at the rest. Our hosts connected with 38 families who shared their contact info. 22 of those families came to Lego Night. Nine have visited on a Sunday.
Maria: And five of them are still coming. One of the moms asked me last week how she could help with next year’s festival.
Pastor Steve: Fewer people came to the event. More people took a step.
Tony: Then I’ll say it again, and this time I’ll mean something different by it. Best one yet. [1]
The church, names and numbers in this example are made up for teaching. The point isn’t the numbers. It’s the shift from “How many came?” to “How many took a next step?”
What changed, and why it worked
[1] They decided what the event was for.
The goal moved from a big crowd to starting relationships and offering one next step. Every other decision flowed from that.
Course connection: Creating a Vision · Process over Program
[2] They placed the event on a path and built the next steps.
The festival became the Explore checkpoint, Lego Night the second checkpoint, and Family Sunday the third. Each one pointed to the next.
Course connection: Identify the Stages · Place the Program · The Big Checkpoints
[3] They made it personal on purpose.
They took what Joan did naturally, learning names, noticing interests and inviting personally, and made it the plan for every host.
Course connection: Making It Personal
[4] They equipped the whole church, one person at a time.
Hosts at the tables and members inviting their own neighbors turned a church-wide event into hundreds of individual connections.
Course connection: Church Wide and Individual · The Buy In
[5] They chose what goes and what stays.
The festival stayed. The hayride, the petting zoo and some of the stations went. Money and people moved to what actually helped families take a step.
Course connection: What Goes and What Stays · Adjusting Ministries · Change the Language
[6] They measured movement.
Tracking second and third steps showed what was working and where families dropped off, so next year’s team will know what to adjust.
Course connection: Measurements · Tracking and Measurements
Making the shift with your own big event
Whatever your church’s big event is, here are five moves that turn it from a program into the start of a process:
1. Ask what it’s for. Finish this sentence: “After this event, we hope families will…” If the answer is “come back next year,” keep asking.
2. Name its stage. Most big community events belong in Explore. Their job is to start something, not finish it.
3. Build the next step first. Before you plan the event, plan the one simple, specific thing you will invite people to next. Put it on the calendar.
4. Turn workers into hosts. Free up some of your best people from running activities so they can learn names and have real conversations.
5. Measure the next step, not the crowd. Count how many people took a second step and a third. Celebrate that number.
Discussion and practice
1. What is your church’s biggest annual event? How do you usually measure whether it was a success?
2. Read the November debrief again. Which lines have you heard, or said, in your own meetings?
3. Does your church have a “Joan”? What does that person do naturally that could become part of the plan?
4. Pick your biggest event and plan its next step. What is it? When is it? Who will personally invite people to it?
5. If you cut one thing from your big event to free up money or people, what would it be, and where would you put those resources instead?
6. Role-play a host conversation at the hot chocolate table. One person plays a parent who came for the free candy. The other practices learning names, asking one question and making a simple invitation.