REAL WORLD LESSON · PROGRAMS TO PROCESS
“We Need a Young Adults Ministry”
What happens when a church solves a problem with a program, and what happens when it builds a process instead
When churches notice a problem, the most natural response is to start something: a new class, a new night, a new ministry with a new name. It feels like action. But a program answers the question “What should we do?” before anyone has asked “Where are people getting stuck, and what is their next step?”
This lesson listens in on the same leadership meeting twice. Same church, same problem, same people around the table.
AROUND THE TABLE
Pastor Dan, the lead pastor
Rob, a longtime elder
Beth, who coordinates small groups
Jessica, 26, who started attending two years ago
The program approach
This is how the meeting goes at most churches. Everyone means well, and everyone wants to help. The numbers in brackets mark the problems explained after the scene.
THE AUGUST LEADERSHIP MEETING
Rob: Have you noticed the young adults are disappearing? My nephew stopped coming after college. Half the kids from our youth group are gone.
Pastor Dan: You’re right. We need a young adults ministry. [1]
Beth: What about Thursday nights? Pizza, a little worship, a talk. Young people love that.
Rob: It needs a name. Something that sounds young. How about “Elevate”?
Pastor Dan: I like it. Let’s launch in September. Big announcement on Sunday, a banner in the lobby, some posts on Instagram. [2]
Jessica: Honestly, I’m not sure another night is what—
Pastor Dan: That’s exactly why we need you, Jessica! You’d be perfect to lead it. [5]
Jessica says yes. She isn’t sure how to say no to the pastor.
Rob: If we get thirty people to the launch, I’ll call that a win. [6]
Nobody asks what Elevate is supposed to lead to. Nobody asks where young adults are already falling away. Nobody asks any young adults besides Jessica, and she didn’t get to finish her sentence. [3]
WHAT HAPPENED NEXT
September: 38 people come to the launch night. Most of them already come on Sundays. Everyone is thrilled.
October: 22 people. Jessica is spending 10 hours a week planning talks, ordering pizza and setting up chairs.
November: 14 people. Three of them were already in a small group on Wednesdays and feel stretched thin. [4]
January: Elevate is “paused.” Jessica is worn out and quietly steps back from serving.
THE FEBRUARY LEADERSHIP MEETING
Rob: I don’t know. Young adults just aren’t very committed these days. [6]
Pastor Dan: Maybe we try again in the fall with a better speaker.
Where it went wrong
[1] It started with a solution, not a question.
Within ten seconds of naming the problem, the answer was “a ministry.” No one asked what the church was trying to help young adults become.
Course connection: Process over Program · Creating a Vision
[2] It never looked at what already existed.
The church already had Sunday worship, small groups and serve teams. Nobody asked how young adults were, or weren’t, connecting to them.
Course connection: Look Inward
[3] It had no place in a path.
Elevate wasn’t a step toward anything. It was a destination with no next step, so when the excitement wore off, there was nowhere to go.
Course connection: Identify the Stages · Place the Program
[4] It never found the real gap.
The people who came to Elevate were mostly already connected. The young adults the church was worried about never showed up, because the program wasn’t built around where they were getting stuck. It also competed with groups people were already in.
Course connection: Find the Gaps
[5] It was built for young adults, not with them.
Jessica was drafted, not listened to. No young adults helped shape it, so nobody owned it but her.
Course connection: Making It Personal · The Buy In
[6] It measured the wrong thing, and then blamed the people.
Success was “thirty at the launch.” When attendance dropped, the conclusion was that young adults aren’t committed, not that the plan missed.
Course connection: Measurements
The process approach
Same meeting, same people, same worry. This time, Pastor Dan slows the conversation down before anyone starts planning. The numbers match the problems above, showing how each one was handled differently.
THE AUGUST LEADERSHIP MEETING
Rob: Have you noticed the young adults are disappearing? My nephew stopped coming after college.
Pastor Dan: I have. Before we start anything new, can we figure out what’s actually happening? What do we want for young adults here? Not just that they show up, but who we hope they become? [1]
Beth: I’d say: that they find real friends here, grow in their faith and find a place to serve. Same as anyone.
Pastor Dan: Good. So let’s look at what we already have. Beth, how many people in their twenties came this year? [2]
Beth: I pulled it before the meeting. 31 came at least once. 19 came more than a few times. But only 3 are in a small group, and 4 serve anywhere.
Rob: So they are coming on Sundays. They’re just not going any further.
Pastor Dan: Right. If our path is Explore, Connect, Grow and Serve, then Sunday is working for them. The gap is Connect. There’s no next step that fits them. [3]
Pastor Dan: Jessica, you’ve been in their shoes. What was that step like for you?
Jessica: Honestly? When I first came, I tried a small group. It met at 7 on a Tuesday, in a house 25 minutes away, and everyone else had kids. They were really nice. I just didn’t go back. [4]
Beth: Every one of our groups looks like that. We built them for young families.
Rob: So it’s not that young adults aren’t committed. It’s that we never gave them a next step that fits.
Pastor Dan: Then let’s not start a whole new ministry. Let’s build the missing step. Jessica, would you be willing to get five or six young adults together and ask them what would work? Not to run it. To help us design it. [5]
Jessica: I’d love that.
TWO WEEKS LATER
Jessica and six young adults meet for coffee. Their ideas shape the plan the team agrees on:
• A monthly lunch right after the second Sunday service. Easy to get to, no extra night, and a clear first checkpoint after Sunday.
• Two new small groups inside the existing small group system: one at a coffee shop downtown on Wednesdays at 7:30, and one online.
• A personal invitation within a week. When a young adult visits, Jessica or one of the others reaches out and invites them to lunch.
• A serve team partner. Anyone who wants to serve is paired with someone on the team who will show them the ropes.
Rob: Do we still need a name? Like “Elevate”?
Jessica: Can we just call it what it is? “Young Adults Lunch.” People know what that means.
Pastor Dan: And let’s decide now how we’ll know it’s working. Not how many people come to lunch. How many people move from Sunday only, into a group, and then into serving. [6]
WHAT HAPPENED NEXT
First lunch: 12 people. Four of them had never been to anything besides Sunday worship.
Three months later: Lunch averages about 15. Nine young adults are in a small group, up from 3. Beth adds a third group.
Six months later: Seven are serving on a team. Two of the young adults now lead the lunch, and Jessica is still serving, not burned out.
THE FEBRUARY LEADERSHIP MEETING
Jessica: The best part is that I’m not running a program. I’m just helping people find their next step.
The church, names and numbers in this example are made up for teaching. The point isn’t the size of the lunch. It’s that people are moving.
What made the difference
[1] A question came before the answer.
Pastor Dan asked what they wanted young adults to become before anyone talked about what to start. That kept the vision bigger than one event.
Course connection: Process over Program · Creating a Vision
[2] They looked inward first.
A simple count showed that young adults were coming on Sundays but not going further. The problem wasn’t attendance at all.
Course connection: Look Inward
[3] They placed the problem on the path.
Naming the stages showed exactly where people were stuck: between Explore and Connect.
Course connection: Identify the Stages · Place the Program
[4] They found the real gap and filled it with a checkpoint.
Jessica’s story revealed the gap. The lunch became a clear checkpoint, and new groups grew inside the system they already had instead of competing with it.
Course connection: Find the Gaps · The Big Checkpoints · Adjusting Ministries
[5] They designed it with the people it was for.
Young adults shaped it, so they owned it. Personal invitations replaced banners and announcements.
Course connection: Making It Personal · The Buy In · Change the Language
[6] They measured movement, not a crowd.
Success meant people taking their next step. When the numbers moved, they could see it. When they didn’t, the team would know what to adjust, without blaming anyone.
Course connection: Measurements · Tracking and Measurements
The difference in one sentence
A program asks, “What should we start?”
A process asks, “Where are people getting stuck, and what is their next step?”
Take it with you: before you start something new
The next time someone in a meeting says, “We need a ministry for…,” pause and ask these questions first:
1. What do we want for these people? Not just attendance. Who do we hope they become?
2. What do we already have? How are they connecting, or not, to what already exists?
3. Where on the path are they stuck? Explore, Connect, Grow or Serve?
4. What is the gap? Ask the people themselves. Their story usually holds the answer.
5. Can we fill the gap inside what we already have? Adjust an existing ministry before adding a new one.
6. Who will help design it? Build it with the people it’s for, not just for them.
7. How will we know it’s working? Measure people moving to their next step, not a crowd at an event.
Discussion and practice
1. Think of a program your church started that later faded. Which parts of the “program approach” meeting sound familiar?
2. Which group at your church are you most worried about right now? Young adults, men, new families, empty nesters? Where on the path do you think they are getting stuck?
3. Do your own “look inward.” For that group, how many come on Sundays? How many are in a group? How many serve? What does that tell you?
4. Role-play the meeting. Assign the four roles and run the “program” version first. Then run it again, with Pastor Dan’s character slowing things down. How did the conversation feel different?
5. Who could be your Jessica? Name one person you could invite to help design the next step.